On Sunday, March 19—just over a year after Saudi Arabia executed 81 men in a single day for taking part in anti-government protests—Formula 1 returned to the Red Sea port city of Jeddah for the annual Saudi Arabian Grand Prix.
The race marked F1’s second event in 2023 following the organization’s season-opener in the Kingdom of Bahrain and saw Red Bull’s Mexican star Sergio Pérez triumph over teammate Max Verstappen at the Jeddah Corniche Circuit. And though the event drew the usual fanfare and excitement expected from an Formula 1 showcase, it also led to fresh accusations of sportswashing from critics.
Last week, Yasser al-Khayyat—the brother of one of the 81 men who were executed in a single day by Saudi authorities—sent a letter to Formula 1 CEO Stefano Domenicali arguing that the organization is helping legitimize the Kingdom’s “heinous crimes.” He also asserted that his brother had been executed for simply taking part in pro-democracy protests.
“They use the spectacle of this sporting championship to distract from the murder of my brother and hundreds of others,” al-Khayyat wrote. “The grand prix carrying on as normal, without even mentioning the atrocities that have just been committed on that same soil, legitimizes these heinous crimes.
“Silence is complicity. It is how the regime gets away with its atrocities and suppresses calls for democratic reforms. If you truly want Formula 1 to be an agent for change, rather than a tool to ‘sportswash’ Saudi abuses, please end Formula 1’s silence.”
Al-Khayyat felt compelled to write his letter after Domenicali argued in a recent interview with The Guardian that Formula 1 was capable of exacting positive change and reform through the organization’s partnerships with controversial regimes such as Bahrain, Saudi Arabia and Qatar.
“I have the duty of running a sport that is more than a sport today,” Domenicali said in his interview with Guardian journalist Giles Richard. “I need to keep the sport in the sport dimension but I also feel that due to the relationships I have and the network we are creating in the world it can adapt to become a positive.”
Domenicali’s argument that sports organizations can use “soft power” to engender positive change in authoritarian regimes is a tired and disingenuous statement that holds no basis in reality. Of the countless entities that have partnered with Saudi Arabia over the past few years, none have been able to coerce any substantive change or reform within the kingdom, as is evidenced by Saudi’s continued oppression. There is also no proof that Formula 1 has ever seriously engaged with human rights in the kingdom.
The Formula 1 CEO’s argument even failed to convince one of his own drivers, Lewis Hamilton, who expressed concerns ahead of this past weekend’s race.
“I still feel that as a sport going to places with human rights issues, such as this one, I feel that the sport is duty bound to raise awareness and try to leave a positive impact,” Hamilton said during the press conference. “And I feel like it needs to do more. What that is, I don’t have all the answers, but I think we always need to try and do more to raise awareness for things that the people are struggling with.”
As authoritarian regimes continue to utilize sports for political gain, Formula 1 has proven to be among the biggest offenders of sportswashing. The 2023 schedule includes events in Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Azerbaijan and Qatar, all of whom have been accused of widespread human rights abuses. The organization will also host a race in Hungary, where a quasi-fascist government is currently dismantling the rule of law and democratic institutions while also targeting women’s rights and the country’s LGBTQ+ community.
To read the rest of this article, please subscribe to Karim Zidan’s Sports Politika Substack. Your support will allow Karim to continue to hold the powers that be to account through his investigative reporting.
